Using MKT to Justify Normal Temperature Excursions during Qualification: Should you?

Warehouse workers image
Paul Daniel, Senior Regulatory Compliance Expert
Paul Daniel
Senior Regulatory Compliance Expert
Published: Jul 1, 2016
Life Science

(Short answer: No. Long answer and some options: Read on!)

Hi Paul,

In regards to the recent MKT webinar, I have a question. Have you ever used MKT as a scientific justification for normal and acceptable excursions of a cold room (normal defrost) during a qualification?  


Thermal Profile Freezer Room Vaisala

Dear A, 

Thanks for attending the webinar on mean kinetic temperature and thanks for the question! 

The simple answer is no;  I haven't tried that tactic personally. My review of the guidance on MKT directly recommends against use of MKT in a refrigerated environment.  I wouldn't do it personally, unless you know the degradation pathways of the product in question, at the temperatures of 8-12°C are well characterized by the assumptions of the Arrhenius equation.

This doesn't make your problem go away, though… 

The traditional tools for dealing with this are still available to us.  Typically, that would be a detailed mapping during a few defrost cycles to accurately characterize their duration and temperature.  Then evaluating how that impacts the product.  Often this might involve measuring actual product temperatures during the defrost cycle, rather than just air temperatures. 

Or it might mean deciding that there are areas in the cold room that simply aren't suitable to store product.   Cold rooms have always had defrost cycles, and we've always dealt with it with traditional tools.  There may be a better way to do it, but I don't think it is MKT. 

Let me know what you choose to do.  I'd be interested to hear your solution. If you have not already read it, here is our application note on mean kinetic temperature.

Best Regards,

Paul Daniel
Sr. Regulatory Compliance Expert / Validation Program Manager


Temperature monitoring fridges warehouse Vaisala


Mechanics of a data logger's installation

Have you heard? Something New from Vaisala…

Here, Mechanical Engineer Timo Sulin-Saaristo describes how tweaking the mechanics of a data logger's installation can make for a snappy install. Our customers wanted mounting options... Timo delivered.

Watch the video

Timo talks about monitoring devices

Paul Daniel, Senior Regulatory Compliance Expert

Paul Daniel

Senior Regulatory Compliance Expert

Paul Daniel is the Senior Regulatory Compliance Expert at Vaisala. He has worked in the GMP-regulated industries for over 20 years helping manufacturers apply good manufacturing practices in a wide range of qualification projects. His specialties include mapping, monitoring, and computerized systems.

At Vaisala, Paul oversees and guides the validation program for the Vaisala viewLinc environmental monitoring system. He serves as a customer advocate to ensure the viewLinc environmental monitoring system matches the demanding requirements of life science and regulated applications.

Paul also shares his GMP experience through regular blog contributions, webinars, and seminars around the world. Paul’s expertise in the demanding GxP world is applicable to any industry where measurement is critical to product quality. Paul is a graduate of University of California, Berkeley, with a bachelor's degree in biology.

Add new comment